What to Expect from a Therapy Consultation in NYC

Once you’ve done some research and narrowed down your list to a few potential therapists, it’s time to start scheduling initial consultations. An initial consultation is a meeting to determine whether the therapist would be a good fit for you. It’s a chance to get to know each other, discuss your treatment options, and make sure you’re a good match.

As the first point of contact, an initial consultation might feel intimidating, especially if you’re new to talk therapy. After all, finding a licensed therapist that matches your preferences is hard work—and now you’ll need to determine whether they’re the right therapist for you. Here’s what to expect during your first appointment to get the most out of your therapy sessions.

therapy consultation NYC

Finding the Right Therapist

The relationship between you and your therapist—your therapeutic relationship—is key to successful therapy, according to the American Psychological Association. As a result, it’s important to ask the right questions during your first therapy session to find the best NYC therapist for your specific mental health needs.

By asking about your therapist’s specialty, credentials, and experience, you’ll be able to figure out whether potential therapists are the right fit for you. To find the right therapist, it’s always a good idea to prepare questions beforehand so you know exactly what to ask during your appointment. Here are some common questions to ask your psychotherapist during your first appointment:

  • What therapeutic approaches do you use? What type of therapy do you recommend for my mental health problems?
  • What’s your training in [cognitive-behavioral therapy, psychodynamic psychotherapy, etc.]?
  • Do you offer different modalities [family therapy, couples counseling, etc.]?
  • How does insurance work with you? How are insurance claims filed?
  • What is your specialty? Do you have experience treating clients with [PTSD, substance abuse, phobias, etc.]?

These questions are important, and so is how you feel about opening up to them. If you have major reservations about your therapist, it’s essential to listen to your gut. The right therapist will provide a sense of warmth, empathy, and compassion while creating a safe space to discuss your specific challenges without judgment.

Ready for an appointment?

Setting Mental Health Goals

Prospective clients seek mental health services for many different reasons. Maybe you’re experiencing relationship issues or seeking treatment for an anxiety disorder—or perhaps you’re looking to learn different ways to manage and improve your mental health. Meanwhile, for some new clients, psychotherapy might be a place to replace self-destructive behaviors with more positive ones.

Regardless of your reason for seeking psychotherapy, consider your long-term goals before your first therapy session. During your first session, your psychologist will ask about your mental health goals and current problems to help you establish the most appropriate treatment plan. This appointment might feel more like information-gathering, while future appointments will focus more on your struggles, challenges, or mental health condition. Some questions your therapist might ask include:

  • Why are you seeking counseling?
  • Are you experiencing any mental health symptoms or specific challenges?
  • Have you sought mental health services in the past?

Your therapist may also ask questions about your career, relationships, childhood, and family members to learn more about your current situation.

How To Prepare for Your First Session

If you’re feeling nervous before your first appointment, preparing for your session can help ease your anxiety so you can get the most out of your consultation. Here are some tips to ensure a successful first point of contact:

  • Create a safe space. If you’re starting online counseling, create a comfortable, private environment that is free of distractions. Whether your therapy sessions are through phone calls or video calls, it’s important to treat online therapy sessions like in-person therapy sessions.
  • Eliminate distractions. Clear your schedule and let people know that you’ll be unavailable during your therapy session. Consider setting aside some time after your appointment to decompress and check in with yourself.
  • Trust the therapeutic process. Talk therapy is going to feel uncomfortable at times—and that’s completely normal. Good psychotherapy is all about building a trusting, strong therapeutic relationship with your psychotherapist. The more comfortable you feel during your therapy sessions, the better your therapist will be able to help you. Don’t be afraid to ask about different types of therapy and different approaches throughout the process to get the most out of your treatment.

Remember, it’s normal to feel uncomfortable during your first few sessions, especially as you’re opening up to a stranger. Your psychotherapist has the skills, training, and experience to help you start feeling better.

Compassionate, Personalized Therapy in NYC

Whether you’re starting in-person therapy for the first time or transitioning to online therapy, finding the right therapist can make all the difference in your mental well-being. The best therapist will make you feel comfortable and safe, even when you’re navigating difficult emotions.

To find the right therapist, reach out to an NYC therapist through The Therapy Group of NYC. We know that finding a good fit can feel overwhelming—and we’re here to make you feel comfortable every step of the way. We’ll connect you to a qualified, empathetic psychiatrist, psychologist, or counselor you feel comfortable with based on your personal preferences and requirements.

A Personalized Approach to Therapy

You want to feel better and make lasting change. We aim to make that happen.

Learn More

Find the right therapist in NYC

Life in New York City can be complicated. Finding and connecting with a therapist should not be.


Not in NYC?

We're part of a trusted therapist network, and can help you search outside of NYC.

Explore Related Articles

Is Adderall Addictive? Understanding the Risks and Reality of...
Explore the risks of Adderall use in high-pressure careers and understand addiction signs and recovery options....
Brad Brenner, Ph.D.
How to Set Healthy Boundaries
If you're looking to foster better relationships, it's important to learn how to set healthy boundaries....
Brad Brenner, Ph.D.
The Essential Guide to Somatic Therapy: Navigating Mind-Body Healing
Dive into the essentials of somatic therapy and how it harnesses your body's healing potential. Explore...
Brad Brenner, Ph.D.